Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders vs Papa Murphy's

Two franchise systems, side by side. For a software vendor, they are not the same opportunity.

More open target
Papa Murphy's
wins 4 of 12 vendor rows

Papa Murphy’s gives us the TAM play—1,014 total units, 965 of them franchised—so the account list alone is 20x larger before a single cold call. With a CURRENT FDD (2026), the brand is actively disclosing and operating, which means location data is fresh, franchisee contact rosters are more accurate, and there’s an in-year compliance cycle to attach our software to. The approved-supplier procurement model also signals that franchisees have some discretion on back-office or POS stack, lowering the gatekeeper friction compared to a rigid corporate mandate. The tradeoff is brutal unit contraction (-3.6% YoY), so net-dollar retention will be a fight: we’d be selling into a shrinking footprint where franchisees are scrutinizing every software line.

Bellacino’s is the timing-and-terrain counterargument. Zero unit growth isn’t expansion, but it isn’t bleeding, either—a flat 52-unit base means every win is pure new-logo revenue without churn from closures eating the pipeline. The lower investment range ($267K–$409K) and light 4% royalty put more cashflow margin inside the franchisee P&L for software budget, and a small, dormant-filing concept often has no incumbent vendor lock-in, giving us terrain with almost no competitive noise. The meaningful compromise is scale: the TAM is tiny, and a single yes-or-no from the franchisor could kill or accelerate the entire play instantly.

Verdict: Papa Murphy’s is the higher-upside software opportunity right now because its massive installed base and active disclosure cycle give us a repeatable, territory-mappable TAM that outweighs the contraction risk, while Bellacino’s is a tactical sniper bet for a budget-rich, empty-calendar account list.

quick_service_restaurant
Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders
quick_service_restaurant
Papa Murphy's
Total units
52
1,014
Franchised units
52
965
Unit growth YoY
0%
-3.596%
Average unit revenue (AUV)
Royalty
4%
5%
Ad fund
2%
2%
Initial franchise fee
$30K
$25K
Investment range (low)
$268K
$450K
Investment range (high)
$409K
$693K
Procurement model
Standards based
Approved supplier
FDD fiscal year
2023
2026
Filing freshness
DORMANT
CURRENT

Go deeper

Common questions

Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders vs Papa Murphy's, answered

Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders has 52 total units and Papa Murphy's has 1,014, so Papa Murphy's is the larger system.
Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders grew units 0% year over year vs -3.596% for Papa Murphy's, so Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders is growing faster.
Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders charges a 4% royalty and Papa Murphy's charges 5%, so Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders has the lower royalty.
Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders's initial franchise fee is $30K and Papa Murphy's's is $25K, so Papa Murphy's has the lower fee.
Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders's initial investment runs $268K–$409K and Papa Murphy's's runs $450K–$693K, so Papa Murphy's requires the larger investment.

See this comparison scored to your product.

The vendor edge changes depending on what you sell. Run your site and we’ll re-weight it.