FranCloud
DirectoryGet access

The Melting Pot vs Papa Murphy's

Two franchise systems, side by side. For a software vendor, they are not the same opportunity.

More open target
Papa Murphy's
wins 3 of 12 vendor rows

Papa Murphy's brings the sheer unit count—1,119 franchised locations—and that scale seems like a quick TAM win. But those units are shrinking, and the brand’s AUV of $680k is a hard ceiling on software spend per store. Worse, the FDD is overdue, a red flag signaling potential franchisee litigation, disclosure compliance risk, or leadership turmoil. Getting a POS or back-office deal through a franchisee base that’s seeing negative comps and an opaque legal status isn’t a pipeline—it’s a collection of stalled approvals and budget objections. The procurement model is open, but the room to monetize is squeezed by unit economics that can’t support a robust per-seat license.

The Melting Pot flips the script entirely. At $2.17M AUV, these are high-ticket, high-touch restaurants where technology is a cost-of-doing-business, not a luxury. A current 2026 FDD means the brand is clean, compliant, and actively selling—exactly the timing when

quick_service_restaurant
The Melting Pot
quick_service_restaurant
Papa Murphy's
Total units
89
1,127
Franchised units
85
1,119
Unit growth YoY
-2.299%
-2.271%
Average unit revenue (AUV)
$2.17M
$681K
Royalty
5%
5%
Ad fund
2.2%
2%
Initial franchise fee
$45K
—
Investment range (low)
$1.62M
$367K
Investment range (high)
$2.74M
$670K
Procurement model
Approved supplier
Approved supplier
FDD fiscal year
2026
2024
Filing freshness
CURRENT
OVERDUE

Go deeper

The Melting Pot franchise profile →Papa Murphy's franchise profile →Browse all franchises →

Common questions

The Melting Pot vs Papa Murphy's, answered

The Melting Pot has 89 total units and Papa Murphy's has 1,127, so Papa Murphy's is the larger system.
The Melting Pot grew units -2.299% year over year vs -2.271% for Papa Murphy's, so Papa Murphy's is growing faster.
The Melting Pot reports $2.17M in average unit revenue and Papa Murphy's reports $681K, so The Melting Pot has the higher AUV.
Both charge a 5% royalty.
The Melting Pot's initial investment runs $1.62M–$2.74M and Papa Murphy's's runs $367K–$670K, so The Melting Pot requires the larger investment.

See this comparison scored to your product.

The vendor edge changes depending on what you sell. Run your site and we’ll re-weight it.

Score it for me →